Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

Should the weight of fashion models be policed? Show more Show less

Fashion models have been in the scrutinizing eyes of the public for decades leading to debates regarding weight and health. These models are widely looked upon for inspiration for fashion and lifestyle, which may pose a problem for the younger generation. Young adults could be idolizing a toxic idealism. Some countries, like Spain and France, have instituted regulations regarding the weight of their models for health reasons. Some countries have not regulated this activity and are in the middle of a hot topic. Should the weight of fashion models be policed and regulated?

No, the weight of fashion models should not be policed Show more Show less

Different fashion companies have a right to whom they hire to model their products.
< Previous (2 of 2 Positions)

Fashion models are autonomous

Models are subject to different rules and, in turn, are much harder to submit to regulations and can turn into a legal battle.
< Previous (2 of 2 Arguments)

Context

The Argument

There are certain countries with regulated BMI standards for their models. However, while the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration can monitor the safety of modeling agencies, this would be in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Turning away someone from a position because of a disability, which includes anorexia nervosa, is against the law. People can fall below a certain BMI and still be considered healthy. They also cannot discriminate against body type, which would be an issue if they placed regulations on BMI.[1] Fashion models also do not have to follow the same rules as regularly employed people because they are contracted through agencies and are not required to perform in certain shows or designs.

Counter arguments

OSHA cannot monitor independently contracted employees because they do not fall under a specific company. They are their employers, so they cannot follow the same rules. There are work-a-rounds to this rule, and that is that individual agencies would need to create rules that only allow models with a BMI above a certain number are allowed to participate. This would require an alteration to the OSHA rules and the Americans with Disability Act .

Framing

Premises

[P1] OSHA monitors workplace violations and dangerous environments, but models are independently contracted. [P2] Turning away someone with a disability, according to the Americans with Disability Act, is against the law. [P3] People can fall below a standard BMI and still be considered healthy based on their ancestry and health conditions unrelated to eating disorders. [P4] Models can choose whether or not to participate in a show.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] OSHA cannot monitor fashion models because they do not work for one specific company.

Proponents

Further Reading

References

  1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4815821/

Explore related arguments

This page was last edited on Tuesday, 28 Apr 2020 at 12:57 UTC