Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
6 comments
TL;DR - The pandemic has meant that this necessary move should be delayed.
Among the main [benefits] (https://www.procon.org/headlines/should-bottled-water-be-banned-top-4-pros-and-cons/) is the environmental impact. Bottled water contributes to large quantities of global waste and so simply stopping the sale of them is a simple way to reducing the environmental impact of waste bottles. Likewise, banning bottled water would save people money and require tap water to be better regulated.
These simple facts remain true today. However, they do not account for life during a pandemic. As has been repeatedly stressed in the government's rhetoric on Covid-19, it is essential to avoid non-essential contact. This has seen coffee shops refuse keep-cups and also say no to refilling reusable water bottles. This is by no means a popular development but it is needed at this time.
By no means is this a declaration that bottled water must stay. Rather, it is an attempt to illustrate how the present world situation means that banning bottled water right now is not feasible.
The act of banning bottled water seems simple enough, but there are instances where this simply is not possible. In the UK, it seems a simple enough task as the drinking water here is of an excellent standard, and you can buy water filters if you still aren't comfortable with the quality of water.
But if we ban bottled water, what does this mean for people who have limited access? For example, people who are homeless and do not have access to tap water, and rely on bottled water to get by? If we are to ban water, we need to make it accessible to everyone first, meaning we need to have more water fountains available, or perhaps places that people can travel to to access clean tap water, if they don't have access to it.
Although I don't think bottled water should be banned it should be heavily discouraged and is only necessary in a few, specific circumstances as it can make water accessible.
Pros
Cons
The bottled water industry is a hazard to local freshwater sources, which are otherwise optimal sources of safe, plastic-free, low-emission water.
Water bottle companies in the United States have been under fire for depleting local water sources and shipping their packaged products across the country. This arrangement involves minimal compensation to the small communities surrounding the aquifers, with large conglomerates such as Nestlé paying a meagre $524 per annum on their pumping rights and raking profits from consumers across the continent.
As of February 2020, states Washington, Maine, and Michigan are either considering or already have anti-bottled water legislation in the pipeline. Washington may be the first to ban companies from tapping into spring-fed water bodies, while the latter states may seek taxation and/or similar restrictions. While these aren't plastic water bottle bans in themselves, the circumstance itself propels the case for this stronger measure.
Water policy specialist at Food and Water Watch Mary Grant succinctly frames the argument: "As water scarcity is becoming a deeper crisis, you want to protect your local water supply so it goes for local purposes. [Bottled water] is not an industry that needs to exist."
A change in how we acquire out water is already necessary given the impacts of plastics, production, and transportation associated with bottled options. This particular concern, regarding small community water bodies, highlights the potential to couple the ban with the empowerment and encouragement of local sourcing initiatives.
I don't believe it should be banned I would hope for more sustainable bottles and a less exploitative way if doing it than buying up a whole local water supply it's should also be rationed by necessity since most people have a tap these days
tbh a bottle is the best container for most liquids.
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!